Collecting and Grading

Is It Worth Getting Comic Books Professionally Graded?

Grading usually pays only for valuable keys, high-grade books and witnessed signatures. Use this rule of thumb to compare value with total grading cost.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. The rule of thumb
  3. Good candidates for grading
  4. Poor candidates for grading
  5. Costs beyond the fee
  6. Downsides to weigh
  7. Benefits to weigh
  8. Common misconceptions

Short answer

Usually only for a few kinds of books: valuable keys, high-grade vintage books and comics with a witnessed signature. For common or low-value comics, the fees, shipping and insurance usually cost more than grading adds to the price.

The rule of thumb

Grade a book only if its expected graded value is higher than its raw value plus all grading costs. Those costs include:

  • The grading fee for your tier
  • Shipping both ways
  • Insurance
  • Membership or dealer fees, if any

The total is often about $40 to $100 or more per book, depending on the service and the book’s value.

Good candidates for grading

  • Keys. First appearances, origins and iconic issues. A slab helps buyers trust the grade.
  • High-grade books. A book already in high grade has more to gain from a slab.
  • Valuable vintage books. Older keys can be worth grading even in low grades, such as 2.0 to 4.0, because their values are high.
  • Witnessed signatures. A CGC Signature Series label, from a signing witnessed by a CGC representative, can add to resale value.

Poor candidates for grading

  • Common modern issues. Most are not worth the cost.
  • Low-grade non-keys. Grading rarely pays for these.
  • Reading copies. A slabbed comic cannot be read safely, so a book you plan to read is a poor candidate.

Modern books, from 1975 on, often need a 9.8 to justify grading, and a 9.6 can be worth far less. Do not assume a new comic will grade 9.8, either, because printing defects are common. Heavily foxed books can also grade lower than you expect.

Costs beyond the fee

Shipping and insurance on both legs add up quickly. Signature Series and pressing add their own fees. If you submit directly, you may also need a membership. If the grader judges a book’s value higher than you declared, it charges the higher tier. For current prices, see how much CGC grading costs.

Downsides to weigh

  • Slabs stop reading. You cannot read a slabbed comic, so buy a reading copy if you need one.
  • Cracking voids the grade. Opening a slab voids its grade.
  • Grades are subjective. Resubmitting the same book can produce a different grade.
  • Restoration is checked. Graders look for restoration. An undisclosed restored book gets a purple label and sells for less.
  • Pressing can help, at a cost. Pressing a bent or wavy book before grading can raise its grade, but it adds an extra fee.
  • Storage still matters. A slab protects against handling damage but not against heat or humidity. See how to store comic books for the long term.

Benefits to weigh

A slab can build buyer confidence and make online sales easier. A graded book is also easier to document for insurance and estate valuation.

Common misconceptions

  • Grading does not make a book valuable. It documents condition.
  • Not every old comic deserves a slab.
  • A 9.8 is not guaranteed for a new comic straight from the shop.
  • Slabbed books are not immune to damage from heat, light or humidity.

For the choice between graders, see CGC vs. CBCS.

The complete guide to collecting and grading

Comic Book Values: What Makes a Comic Worth Money
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →