The short answer
Comic book errors are mistakes made in producing a comic, or mistakes in its story and art. Production errors include miscut pages, off-center covers and missing pages. Content errors include wrong costume colors, misspelled names and continuity slips. Most errors add little or no value. A few famous ones command a premium.
Printing and production errors
- Miscut. Pages or covers trimmed in the wrong place.
- Miswrap. The cover sits off-center on the interior.
- Off-register color. Color printed out of line with the black linework.
- Missing or duplicate pages. Pages left out, or printed twice.
- Blank pages. Pages printed with nothing on them.
- Upside-down interiors.
- Missing staples.
- Missing cover ink.
Grading companies such as CGC and CBCS account for manufacturing defects. A severe miscut or miswrap can lower the grade.
Content errors
Content errors are mistakes in the story and art:
- Wrong costume colors
- Misspelled names
- Misplaced or mislettered dialogue
- Continuity contradictions
Marvel’s “No-Prize,” started by Stan Lee in the 1960s, rewarded readers who spotted or explained errors.
Notable examples
- Incredible Hulk #1 (1962). The Hulk was gray in this issue. He was switched to green from #2, because gray printed inconsistently.
- Amazing Spider-Man #121 (1973). The art shows the Brooklyn Bridge, while the caption says George Washington Bridge.
- Venom: Lethal Protector #1 (1993). A black-cover error that is one of the most valuable error comics.
- League of Extraordinary Gentlemen #5 (2000). DC recalled and pulped this issue over an advertisement it contained, so few copies survive.
- Elseworlds 80-Page Giant (1999). DC recalled this issue over a gag involving baby Superman. Some copies were sold outside the US.
Do errors make a comic valuable?
Not usually. An error does not make a comic valuable by itself, and most printing errors add little. Collectors pay premiums mainly for famous or dramatic errors, such as the black-cover Venom. For recalled issues, value depends on whether surviving copies are scarce and demand exists.
What is not an error
Several things get confused with errors:
- Price variants and newsstand editions. These are intentional, not errors. See variant covers.
- Retailer stickers or stamps. These are added by stores, not by printers.
- Damage after printing. Tears, stains and creases are not factory errors.
Common misconceptions
- An error does not automatically make a comic valuable.
- Price variants and newsstand editions are not errors.
- Retailer stickers are not printing errors.
- Damage after printing is not a factory error.
Errors are sometimes confused with fakes. For the difference, see counterfeit comics.