Collecting and Grading

What are the errors of comic books?

Comic book errors are printing or production mistakes, or story and art mistakes. Here are the common types, notable examples, and which errors add value.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Printing and production errors
  3. Content errors
  4. Notable examples
  5. Do errors make a comic valuable?
  6. What is not an error
  7. Common misconceptions

The short answer

Comic book errors are mistakes made in producing a comic, or mistakes in its story and art. Production errors include miscut pages, off-center covers and missing pages. Content errors include wrong costume colors, misspelled names and continuity slips. Most errors add little or no value. A few famous ones command a premium.

Printing and production errors

  • Miscut. Pages or covers trimmed in the wrong place.
  • Miswrap. The cover sits off-center on the interior.
  • Off-register color. Color printed out of line with the black linework.
  • Missing or duplicate pages. Pages left out, or printed twice.
  • Blank pages. Pages printed with nothing on them.
  • Upside-down interiors.
  • Missing staples.
  • Missing cover ink.

Grading companies such as CGC and CBCS account for manufacturing defects. A severe miscut or miswrap can lower the grade.

Content errors

Content errors are mistakes in the story and art:

  • Wrong costume colors
  • Misspelled names
  • Misplaced or mislettered dialogue
  • Continuity contradictions

Marvel’s “No-Prize,” started by Stan Lee in the 1960s, rewarded readers who spotted or explained errors.

Notable examples

  • Incredible Hulk #1 (1962). The Hulk was gray in this issue. He was switched to green from #2, because gray printed inconsistently.
  • Amazing Spider-Man #121 (1973). The art shows the Brooklyn Bridge, while the caption says George Washington Bridge.
  • Venom: Lethal Protector #1 (1993). A black-cover error that is one of the most valuable error comics.
  • League of Extraordinary Gentlemen #5 (2000). DC recalled and pulped this issue over an advertisement it contained, so few copies survive.
  • Elseworlds 80-Page Giant (1999). DC recalled this issue over a gag involving baby Superman. Some copies were sold outside the US.

Do errors make a comic valuable?

Not usually. An error does not make a comic valuable by itself, and most printing errors add little. Collectors pay premiums mainly for famous or dramatic errors, such as the black-cover Venom. For recalled issues, value depends on whether surviving copies are scarce and demand exists.

What is not an error

Several things get confused with errors:

  • Price variants and newsstand editions. These are intentional, not errors. See variant covers.
  • Retailer stickers or stamps. These are added by stores, not by printers.
  • Damage after printing. Tears, stains and creases are not factory errors.

Common misconceptions

  • An error does not automatically make a comic valuable.
  • Price variants and newsstand editions are not errors.
  • Retailer stickers are not printing errors.
  • Damage after printing is not a factory error.

Errors are sometimes confused with fakes. For the difference, see counterfeit comics.

The complete guide to collecting and grading

Comic Book Values: What Makes a Comic Worth Money
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →