Short answer
For a new submission, CGC is the practical choice. CBCS, once a serious second option, reportedly stopped taking new comic submissions in 2026. Confirm its current status on CBCS’s own website before you send anything. If you already own books in CBCS slabs, those slabs keep their grades.
What changed at CBCS
Reports in 2026 said CBCS would stop accepting new comic submissions after April 17, 2026. One comics retailer’s summary of those reports says the parent company cited a shift in focus toward its core brand, and that comic grading was folded into PSA, a related company. Later reports said CBCS had told customers with pending orders that it could no longer process some of them, and had begun cancelling orders and issuing refunds. Confirm all of this on CBCS’s website, because the situation has been changing.
If you already own CBCS-graded books
A book in a CBCS slab keeps its grade and label. Reports say CBCS’s certificate-verification database remains online, so buyers can still check a book’s grading history. What stops is the supply: no new books will be added to CBCS holders.
Moving a book from CBCS to CGC usually means cracking the CBCS slab and resubmitting the book. Cracking voids the grade, and the resubmission costs a full grading fee. That makes sense only for a book whose value clearly justifies the cost.
Same scale, different labels
Both graders use a 0.5 to 10.0 scale, so a 9.8 describes the same physical condition in either holder. The labels differ:
- CGC: blue Universal for unrestored books, purple for restored, green for qualified, yellow for Signature Series and gray for conserved.
- CBCS: blue Universal, yellow Verified Signature, purple Restored and others.
Both flag restoration with a distinct label, so a restored book is hard to mistake for an original.
The resale premium
CGC slabs generally sell for more than CBCS slabs at the same grade. Estimates vary. A commonly cited range is about 10 to 30 percent, and the gap is widest on in-demand modern keys. Part of the reason is buyer familiarity, and part is that CGC has the larger share of population data. The premium reflects the market. It does not mean one company grades more strictly than the other.
Signature programs
CGC’s Signature Series requires a CGC witness at the signing and produces a yellow label. CBCS ran a separate Verified Signature program. Policies on unwitnessed signatures have differed between the companies and have changed over time, so check each company’s current rules before you submit.
Population reports and a smaller option
Both companies publish population data, and CGC’s is larger. Use both to judge scarcity, and check certification numbers online. A smaller third grader, PGX, generally sells below both.
For what CGC charges, see how much CGC grading costs. For whether grading is worth it at all, see is it worth getting comic books professionally graded?
Common misconceptions
- Grades are not interchangeable in price. A CBCS 9.8 usually sells below a CGC 9.8.
- Neither company is objectively stricter in every case. Both vary from book to book.
- The cheaper fee is not always the better value if you lose the resale premium.
- A slab’s grade does not transfer when you crack it and resubmit.
To confirm a slab is genuine before you buy or sell it, see how to spot a fake comic.