Collecting and Grading

How to Tell if a Comic Book Is a First Printing

How to tell if a comic is a first printing: check the indicia and banners, read the UPC add-on with care, and rule out facsimile and other reprints.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. Check the indicia
  3. Read the UPC add-on, with care
  4. Look for banners and cover changes
  5. Trades and graphic novels: the number line
  6. Newsstand, direct and price variants
  7. Reprints that can look original
  8. Where to verify
  9. Common misconceptions

Short answer

Check the indicia first, which is the small block of print on the first or second page. Then look for cover banners, the printing digit in the UPC add-on, and any changes in color or art. Later printings usually say so. Rule out reprints, which can look like originals.

Check the indicia

The indicia is the small print on the first or second page, or inside the front cover. Look for “First Printing” or “1st Printing.” Later printings often say “2nd Printing,” “Second Printing” or similar.

Older comics often omitted a first-printing statement, because only one run existed. A missing statement on a vintage book does not prove it is a first printing. Check for reprint editions too.

Read the UPC add-on, with care

On many modern comics, the five-digit add-on beside the barcode includes a printing digit. The last digit is commonly the printing number, with 1 meaning a first printing and 2 a second.

Codes vary by publisher and era, and the coding has changed over time. Check the code against a reference such as the Grand Comics Database before you rely on it. Vintage comics, and some direct-edition books that used publisher logos instead of a barcode, do not carry this code, so this check does not apply to them.

Look for banners and cover changes

  • Banners. Some publishers print labels such as “2nd Printing Variant” on the front cover. Modern reprints often say “2nd Printing” on the cover.
  • Color changes. Later printings of famous issues sometimes change the cover color, such as the background or the shade of red.
  • Logo and art changes. Some late-1980s and 1990s second printings used gold or silver logos or different cover colors.

Trades and graphic novels: the number line

Collected editions and graphic novels use a different method. Look at the copyright page for a number line, such as “10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1.” The lowest number shown is the printing. If the line starts at 2 or higher, the book is not a first printing, even if it says “First Edition.”

Newsstand, direct and price variants

Newsstand and direct editions are both first printings. Price variants, such as the 35¢ Star Wars #1, and Canadian price variants are first printings too. For more on these, see variant covers.

Reprints that can look original

Rule these out before you pay a first-printing price:

  • Famous First Editions (DC, 1974 to 1979): tabloid-size reprints.
  • Golden Record reprints (1966): Amazing Spider-Man #1 and Fantastic Four #1, packaged with records.
  • Marvel Milestone Editions (1990s).
  • DC Millennium Editions (2000 to 2001).
  • Facsimile Editions (2019 onward): modern barcode and price, and the word “Facsimile” on the cover.

Reprint titles, such as Marvel Masterworks and DC Archive Editions, collect old stories. They are not first printings of those stories. For more on reprints and fakes, see counterfeit comics.

Where to verify

The Grand Comics Database (comics.org) lets you compare images and publisher details. Publisher information and collector guides help too. If you are still unsure, ask a reputable dealer or grader before you buy or sell.

Common misconceptions

  • A “first edition” trade is not a first printing if its number line starts at 2 or higher.
  • Newsstand copies are not reprints.
  • A missing “second printing” note on a vintage book does not prove it is a first printing.
  • Facsimile Editions look original but have modern barcodes and prices.

The complete guide to collecting and grading

Comic Book Values: What Makes a Comic Worth Money
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →