What foxing is
Foxing is the name for small brown, tan or orange-red spots that appear on old paper. Collectors sometimes call them rust or age spots. On comics, they show up most often on covers and page edges, and they are easier to see on dark or solid-color covers.
Foxing is not surface dirt. It is in the paper, so you cannot wipe it off.
How foxing differs from other damage
Several kinds of damage can look similar at first glance:
- Tanning or browning. Acidic paper, especially cheap newsprint, darkens as it ages. The color is even across the page. This is not foxing.
- Water stains. These look different and usually follow a wet event.
- Mold. Mold can appear as fuzzy or powdery patches, and it can keep spreading. Treat it with care, as described below.
What causes foxing
Experts still debate the cause. The two leading explanations are:
- Fungal growth. Fungal spores in the paper can become active when humidity is high.
- Oxidation. Trace metals, such as iron, in the paper can oxidize and leave rust-colored marks.
Humidity is the main trigger. Risk rises sharply once relative humidity goes above roughly 60 to 65 percent. Books kept in basements, garages, attics or humid climates are more often affected. Foxing is not limited to old books, though. Books from any era can fox.
How foxing affects the grade
Grading companies such as CGC and CBCS treat foxing as a defect and note it in their grader notes. Even light foxing usually keeps a book out of the highest 9.x grades. Heavy foxing can drop a book into the mid or low grades. How much it costs depends on the grader and on where the spots sit.
If you are deciding whether a foxed book is worth a slab, see is it worth getting comic books professionally graded?
Can foxing be removed?
Generally not safely. Foxing is embedded in the paper, so surface cleaning does not reach it.
Some restorers use chemical washing or bleaching. Grading companies may classify these treatments as restoration or as conservation, depending on the treatment and the grader. Restoration can carry a visible label and lower the book’s value. Chemical treatments also carry a risk of weakening or bleaching the paper. Pressing does not remove foxing.
Avoid do-it-yourself fixes:
- Home bleach can damage the paper and lower value.
- Erasers can abrade the surface.
- Strong chemicals can weaken paper or leave it bleached.
How to stop foxing from spreading
Foxing grows with moisture, so the goal is to keep humidity steady and low:
- Aim for about 30 to 50 percent relative humidity and around 65 to 70°F.
- Store away from exterior walls and floors. Keep boxes off concrete.
- Use acid-free, buffered boards and Mylar or polypropylene bags. Bags help with handling, but humidity can still reach inside them. For more on storage, see how to store comic books for the long term.
- Use silica gel or a dehumidifier in damp rooms, and check the level with a hygrometer.
- Keep heavily foxed books apart from clean ones. This is a common precaution against spreading spores.
If the spots are spreading, that suggests active moisture. Move the collection to a drier space before anything else.
If you find foxing in your collection
- Check the room. Measure humidity with a hygrometer, and look for leaks, damp walls or poor airflow.
- Move the books to a drier place.
- Separate the affected books from the rest of the collection.
- Skip home cleaning. If a book is valuable, ask a professional conservator or grader before any treatment.
If a book also shows mold, wear a mask while handling it, because mold spores can irritate the lungs.
Common misconceptions
- Foxing is not just dirt. It cannot be wiped off.
- Bagging alone does not prevent it. Humidity gets inside bags.
- It is not only a Golden Age problem. Books from any era can fox.
- Home bleach and erasers will not help. They can damage the paper and lower value.