How Comics Work

Understanding Comics: How Panels, Gutters and Closure Work

A practical guide to Scott McCloud's Understanding Comics, covering the chapter 2 vocabulary, what gutters do, closure and the six panel transitions.

On this page
  1. What the book is
  2. Chapter 2: The Vocabulary of Comics
  3. Gutters and closure (Chapter 3)
  4. The six panel-to-panel transitions
  5. What the rest of the book covers
  6. Common misconceptions

Scott McCloud’s Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art is a comic about comics. Chapter 2, “The Vocabulary of Comics,” covers the basic building blocks of how pictures work as a storytelling language. The gutter, the blank space between panels, comes up in Chapter 3, “Blood in the Gutter,” along with closure and the six ways one panel can lead to the next.

What the book is

Understanding Comics was first published in 1993 by Tundra, with a HarperPerennial edition in 1994. It runs about 215 pages and is drawn entirely in comics form, with McCloud appearing as a cartoon narrator. It won the 1994 Eisner Award for Best Comics-Related Book.

McCloud’s definition from Chapter 1 is a useful starting point. He describes comics as “juxtaposed pictorial and other images in deliberate sequence, intended to convey information and/or to produce an aesthetic response in the viewer.”

He builds on the term “sequential art,” which Will Eisner popularized in Comics and Sequential Art (1985).

Chapter 2: The Vocabulary of Comics

Chapter 2 opens with René Magritte’s painting The Treachery of Images, which shows a pipe above the words “This is not a pipe.” McCloud uses the painting to make a point about drawings: a picture is an icon that represents a thing, not the thing itself.

The chapter builds several ideas from there:

  • Icons. A simple drawing can stand in for a person, object or idea, and readers read it as that thing.
  • Amplification through simplification. Leaving out detail can make the important features stand out more clearly.
  • Universality. A simpler face can represent more people, so readers may find it easier to see themselves in the character.
  • The realism-to-cartoon scale. Images can be placed on a line from realistic to highly simplified, and creators move along it for different effects.
  • The masking effect. A cartoony character set against a realistic background can feel more believable as a result. McCloud uses Hergé’s Tintin as an example.
  • The Big Triangle. The chapter closes with a triangle whose corners are reality, language (meaning) and the picture plane (abstraction). Most images sit somewhere between those points.

If you are summarizing Chapter 2 for a class or a quick reread, the core message is that comics rely on simplified images that readers learn to interpret.

Gutters and closure (Chapter 3)

The gutter is the blank space between panels. It can look like nothing is there, but McCloud treats it as the place where the reader does much of the work.

He calls the reader’s mental process closure: connecting two separate, still images and filling in the action, time or motion between them. In McCloud’s words, closure means observing the parts but perceiving the whole.

Many creators treat the gutter as a pacing tool. A narrow gutter can make action feel quick, while a wider one can suggest a pause or a larger jump in time. Artists also break the gutter on purpose, for example by letting a character, weapon or speech balloon cross a panel border for shock or energy. These choices are craft decisions, not rules from the book.

The six panel-to-panel transitions

Chapter 3 also sorts the jump from one panel to the next into six types:

  1. Moment-to-moment. Small changes within the same moment.
  2. Action-to-action. One subject moves through a series of actions.
  3. Subject-to-subject. The scene stays the same, but attention moves from one subject to another.
  4. Scene-to-scene. The reader jumps across a significant distance in time or space.
  5. Aspect-to-aspect. The panels show different views of one place, mood or idea.
  6. Non-sequitur. The panels have no clear logical connection.

In McCloud’s informal sample, most transitions in mainstream US comics were action-to-action. Aspect-to-aspect transitions were much more common in the Japanese comics he discusses. These figures come from his own count, not a formal study, so treat them as illustrations of a tendency.

What the rest of the book covers

  • Chapter 4, “Time Frames”: Comics show time through space. Panel size and shape change how long a moment feels.
  • Chapter 7, “The Six Steps”: McCloud breaks any art into six steps: idea/purpose, form, idiom, structure, craft and surface.
  • Chapter 8, “A Word About Color” and Chapter 9, “Putting It All Together” cover color and the book’s wider argument.

McCloud followed the book with Reinventing Comics (2000) and Making Comics (2006). Making Comics is the closer of the two to a practical guide. Understanding Comics is an explanation of how comics work, not a how-to-draw book.

Common misconceptions

  • Closure and the six transitions are in Chapter 3, not Chapter 2. Chapter 2 is the vocabulary chapter.
  • McCloud did not invent “sequential art.” Eisner popularized the term.
  • The gutter is not just empty space. It is where readers connect panels.
  • The transition percentages are informal. They are a rough count, not statistics.
  • It is not a drawing manual. It explains the medium, and Making Comics is closer to a how-to.

For more on the page itself, see comic page layout for panel counts and page turns, and speech balloons and lettering for the text elements McCloud calls the vocabulary of comics. For the art side of the realism scale, see comic art styles. If you want to compare the medium with prose, comics vs. graphic novels explains the terms.

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →