Ben-Day dots are evenly sized, evenly spaced dots of a single color, printed in a regular pattern to create a flat tint or shading. Comics printers used them to add color cheaply, because a few inks and a simple dot pattern could produce many shades and secondary colors.
Who Ben-Day was
The process is named after Benjamin Henry Day Jr. (1838 to 1916), an illustrator and printer who developed it in 1879. He was the son of Benjamin Day, the founder of the New York Sun (1833).
How the dots create color and tone
The dots are always the same size and spaced evenly across an area. The eye blends them together, so spacing changes the color you see:
- Widely spaced red dots on white look pink.
- Closely spaced red dots look like a deeper red.
- Yellow and cyan dots placed together read as green.
The principle is similar to pointillism, the painting method that uses small dots of color. The difference is that Ben-Day dots are printed in regular patterns and stay uniform in size.
Why comics used them
Pulp comics of the 1950s and 1960s used Ben-Day dots in the four process colors (cyan, magenta, yellow and black) to add inexpensive shading and secondary colors such as green, orange and flesh tones. Newsprint paper and tight budgets made full-color reproduction costly, so the dots were a practical answer to a printing constraint.
Artists could buy sheets of dots from art and stationery suppliers, in different sizes and spacings. Colorists marked up guides with coded percentages, and the printer’s plates did the rest.
Cheap paper and loose registration (how well the color plates line up) made the dots and any misalignment visible. Many people now see that visible texture as part of the vintage look.
Ben-Day, halftone and screentone
These three terms are often confused:
- Ben-Day dots are uniform in size and make flat tints.
- Halftone dots vary in size to reproduce continuous tones, such as photographs.
- Screentone is the black-and-white equivalent. Black-and-white comics and manga often use adhesive sheets of dots or lines, sold under brands such as Zip-a-Tone.
Not every dotted comic is Ben-Day. Many are halftone or screentone.
Roy Lichtenstein and the dots
Pop artist Roy Lichtenstein made the dots famous in fine art. In paintings such as Whaam! (1963) and Drowning Girl (1963), he enlarged the dots, applying them by hand and with stencils. Those works borrowed panels from existing comics, including art by Irv Novick and Tony Abruzzo, and the lack of credit drew criticism. Lichtenstein did not invent the dots. He borrowed the printing technique and made it a style.
What replaced them
Digital coloring arrived in the late 1980s and 1990s, and it changed comic production. By the 1990s the dot process had largely given way in mainstream printing. Modern retro comics use digital dot patterns to imitate the look.
Common misconceptions
- Ben-Day dots and halftone are not the same thing. Ben-Day dots are uniform; halftone dots vary in size.
- Lichtenstein did not invent the dots. He borrowed a printing technique.
- Not every dotted look is Ben-Day. Many are halftone or screentone.
- Early comics used the dots for cost reasons, not as a style choice. Artists such as Lichtenstein later made them a style.
For the drawing styles that comics and pop art use, see comic art styles. For how manga uses screentone in black-and-white pages, see why manga reads right to left. For how print format affects comic production, see comic page layout.