Short answer: There is no single answer. “#1” can mean the most important comic, the most valuable, the best-selling single issue or the best-selling series. The usual answer for “most important” is Action Comics #1 (June 1938), which introduced Superman. For the best-selling single issue, the usual answer is X-Men #1 (1991).
Four meanings of “#1”
- Most important: Action Comics #1, for its role in starting the superhero genre.
- Most valuable: Graded copies of key early issues, which can sell for millions of dollars.
- Best-selling single issue: X-Men #1 (1991), at about 8.1 million copies according to Guinness.
- Best-selling series: One Piece, with more than 500 million copies in circulation by its publisher’s count, or Asterix, with about 380 to 390 million albums.
Most important: Action Comics #1
Action Comics #1 (cover-dated June 1938) introduced Superman, created by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster. It is widely described as the start of the superhero genre, which makes it the most common answer to “most important.” For more on influence, see our most influential comic books guide.
Its print run is estimated at about 200,000 copies. The number of surviving copies is uncertain, with estimates ranging from about 50 to 100 or more.
Action Comics #1 was not the first comic book. Famous Funnies (1934) is usually cited as the first comic sold on US newsstands. For more on the period, see our Golden Age guide.
Most valuable: graded Golden Age keys
Value is driven by rarity, demand and condition. Professional grading services assign each copy a grade, and a high grade on a rare issue can sell for very large sums.
- An Action Comics #1 graded 8.5 sold for $6 million at Heritage Auctions in April 2024.
- An Amazing Fantasy #15 (the first Spider-Man) graded 9.6 sold for $3.6 million at Heritage in September 2021.
- Detective Comics #27, the first Batman, is the other Golden Age key most often mentioned.
Superman #1 (1939) has also sold for multi-million-dollar prices. Records change with each auction, so check current results before relying on any figure.
Best-selling single issue: X-Men #1
X-Men #1 (October 1991), by Chris Claremont and Jim Lee, sold about 8.1 million copies according to Guinness World Records, which recognizes it as the best-selling single comic issue. It had five cover variants, labeled 1A to 1E.
Many of those copies went to collectors, so the figure reflects early-1990s speculation as much as reader demand. For more on why sales figures from that period are hard to read, see the best-selling comics and manga guide.
Best-selling series
Counting series rather than issues changes the answer. One Piece has more than 500 million copies in circulation by its publisher’s count. Among European comics, Asterix has sold about 380 to 390 million albums since 1959.
Earlier contenders for the first comic
Some readers ask which comic came first. The answer depends on the definition.
- Histoire de M. Vieux Bois (1837), by Rodolphe Töpffer, is sometimes cited as an early comic.
- Funnies on Parade (1933) was a promotional reprint book, and it is often cited for setting the standard size.
- Famous Funnies (1934) is usually cited as the first comic book sold on US newsstands.
Why a #1 is not automatically valuable
Many modern #1 issues are printed in huge numbers, so they are common. A first issue is valuable only if the title is in demand and the copy is in good condition. Many #1 issues from the 1990s and later sell for modest prices.
Reprints and facsimiles
Many copies sold as Action Comics #1 are reprints or facsimiles, including a 1974 Famous First Edition and a 1976 giveaway from Safeguard. Check the printing and any grading label before buying.
How prices are tracked
The Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide, published since 1970, is the standard US price reference. Auction results are another source. Record prices apply to specific graded copies, not to every copy of an issue.
Common misconceptions
- Action Comics #1 was not the first comic book. Newsstand comics date back to 1934.
- A #1 issue is not automatically valuable. Print runs and condition matter more.
- Record prices apply to specific copies. They do not set the price of every copy.