Short answer: Yes, in Japan and worldwide by units. In the United States, it depends on where you look. Manga is the biggest graphic novel category in US bookstores, but superhero comics from Marvel and DC still lead in comic shops.
Japan: the world’s largest comics market
Japan has the largest comics market in the world. Industry estimates put it at roughly ¥680 billion to ¥700 billion a year in the early 2020s. Digital sales now make up about two-thirds of the Japanese manga market, and that share is still growing.
Print has fallen from its peak. Weekly Shōnen Jump reached about 6.53 million copies per issue in 1995, and its print circulation is now about 1 to 1.3 million.
The US: two different markets
The US comics market is split into two channels, and they point in different directions.
- Bookstores: Manga became the biggest graphic novel category in the US bookstore channel, based on BookScan tracking by Circana. Children’s graphic novels also do well here. Dav Pilkey’s Dog Man and Raina Telgemeier’s books outsell most superhero titles in bookstores.
- Comic shops: In the “direct market” of specialist shops, superhero floppies from Marvel and DC still lead.
The total US comics and graphic novel market was roughly $2 billion at its 2021 peak and has been lower since. Estimates vary by source, so treat the exact figure with care.
Why manga volumes sell well
Several factors help manga volumes sell:
- Format and price. A manga volume has about 180 to 200 pages. A US floppy has about 20 to 22 story pages and typically costs $3.99 to $4.99. A volume usually costs less per page than a floppy.
- Finished, numbered volumes. Many readers find manga easier to start because its stories are often complete and numbered. Superhero continuity, with frequent crossovers and reboots, can be harder for new readers to follow.
- Range of genres. Manga covers sports, fantasy, romance, horror, slice-of-life and history, so it reaches readers who do not read superhero comics.
- Anime adaptations. Anime often sends viewers to the source manga, which helps sales in both formats.
Units are not directly comparable
Comparing “copies” across formats can mislead for three reasons:
- Content per unit differs. A manga volume is roughly equal to eight to ten floppies’ worth of story.
- Manga figures are publisher print runs. They are not verified retail sales.
- US single-issue figures are retailer orders. They do not measure how many copies readers bought.
For more on how sales are counted, see our best-selling comics and manga guide.
What circulation figures do and do not show
The publisher of One Piece reports more than 500 million copies in circulation, which is more than any Western comic series by that measure. That figure is useful for showing scale, but it is not a record of retail sales. Publisher figures are updated over time and are not always comparable with each other.
Are Western comics declining?
Not necessarily. European bande dessinée, including Tintin and Asterix, remains strong, and US kids’ graphic novels sell well. The change is largely about where and how comics are sold. Bookstores and digital platforms have grown, while comic shops still depend heavily on monthly superhero issues.
Reported milestones
A 2019 Rutgers University press release said that Japanese or Japanese-inspired comics and graphic novels had reportedly outsold superhero comics in the US for the first time the year before. It is a reported milestone, not a complete accounting of the market.
Summary
- Japan and worldwide: Manga leads by units, with digital sales a growing share.
- US bookstores: Manga is the biggest graphic novel category.
- US comic shops: Marvel and DC superhero issues still lead.
- Comparisons: Units, print runs and retailer orders are not directly comparable.
For the biggest-selling series in each category, see the best-selling comics and manga of all time.