Short answer: The Comics Code Authority (CCA) was a self-regulatory body that reviewed comics before publication. The Comics Magazine Association of America (CMAA) set it up in September 1954, and the Code was adopted on October 26, 1954. Approved issues carried an “Approved by the Comics Code Authority” seal on the cover. Marvel dropped the Code in 2001, and DC and Archie quit in 2011.
Why the Code was created
The Code grew out of public alarm over comics’ content. Psychiatrist Fredric Wertham’s Seduction of the Innocent (1954) argued that comics contributed to juvenile delinquency. A Senate subcommittee on juvenile delinquency held hearings in April and June 1954, with Senator Estes Kefauver prominent among its members. William Gaines, the publisher of EC Comics, testified.
The industry formed the CMAA to head off government censorship. The Code was self-regulation rather than law, and the hearings did not produce censorship legislation.
What the 1954 Code said
The original Code set strict rules:
- Good had to triumph over evil, and criminals had to be punished.
- The words “horror” and “terror” could not appear in titles.
- Vampires, werewolves and zombies were not allowed.
- Gruesome violence, excessive blood and sympathetic portrayals of criminals were restricted.
- Authority figures had to be respected.
- Sex and “perversion” were strictly limited.
Historians have argued that the rules on sex and perversion kept gay and lesbian characters out of mainstream comics for decades.
Judge Charles F. Murphy, a New York magistrate, was the first Code administrator.
Who joined and who did not
Not every publisher joined. Dell never did, and neither did Classics Illustrated, so Dell was the biggest holdout. EC dropped its horror and crime titles. Its humor title, Mad, became a magazine in 1955 and stayed outside the Code.
Why a “voluntary” code worked
The Code was voluntary in name, but distributors and newsstands would not carry comics without the seal. Publishers that wanted newsstand distribution had little choice but to submit their books for approval.
The 1971 revision
Marvel published a three-part Amazing Spider-Man storyline (#96–98) about drug abuse, printed without the seal. The story was produced at the request of the federal Department of Health, Education, and Welfare. The Code was revised in 1971 and relaxed its rules on the depiction of drugs. For how this fits into the wider history of influential books, see the most influential comic books.
Direct market and non-Code books
From the 1970s, specialist comic shops, known as the direct market, gave publishers a way to sell comics directly to fans. That made it possible to sell books without the seal. Warren Publishing’s magazines, such as Creepy (1964), also got around the Code by being sold as magazines rather than comics.
The 1989 revision
The Code was revised again in 1989, loosening its restrictions further. Publishers began exploring more mature themes and a wider range of characters.
The end of the seal
Marvel stopped using the Code in 2001 and adopted its own rating system. In January 2011, DC and Archie Comics dropped the seal, which ended the Code’s role in mainstream comics. The Comic Book Legal Defense Fund acquired the seal in 2011.
Wertham’s reputation
Wertham’s conclusions were influential at the time, but later scholarship has questioned them. Historian Carol Tilley’s 2012 research argued that Wertham manipulated his case data, which has added to doubts about his conclusions. For the era that came before the Code, see the Golden Age of comic books. For the crime comics the Code affected most, see our noir comics guide.
Common misconceptions
- The Code was not a government law. It was industry self-regulation.
- The Senate hearings produced no censorship legislation.
- Not every publisher joined. Dell was the biggest holdout.
- Horror did not vanish entirely. Warren’s magazines kept it alive outside the Code.