Comics History

What is a noir style book?

A noir style book usually has a crime plot, a bleak tone and morally compromised characters. Here is where the term came from and how to spot one.

On this page
  1. Where the term comes from
  2. Hardboiled roots
  3. Common traits of a noir book
  4. Noir vs hardboiled vs mystery
  5. Noir beyond the 1940s and the US
  6. Noir in comics
  7. Common misconceptions

Short answer: A noir style book is usually a crime story with a bleak, fatalistic tone, morally compromised characters and an unhappy ending. The word describes outlook and atmosphere rather than a particular plot or art style, so a noir book does not have to be black-and-white.

Where the term comes from

“Noir” has two origins. In French, Gallimard’s Série Noire imprint, founded in 1945 by Marcel Duhamel, published American hardboiled crime fiction in translation and gave the name roman noir to that kind of book. In 1946, the French critic Nino Frank used the term film noir to describe a group of American crime films.

Hardboiled roots

Noir fiction grew out of American hardboiled crime writing of the 1920s to 1940s. Black Mask, a pulp magazine founded in 1920, was the key outlet for the style. Several writers shaped it:

  • Dashiell Hammett: Red Harvest (1929) and The Maltese Falcon (1930).
  • Raymond Chandler: The Big Sleep (1939), which introduced Philip Marlowe.
  • James M. Cain: The Postman Always Rings Twice (1934). Double Indemnity was serialized in 1936 and published as a book in 1943.
  • Jim Thompson: The Killer Inside Me (1952). Cornell Woolrich and David Goodis also helped shape the style.

Crime comics of the same decades are covered in our Golden Age guide.

Common traits of a noir book

Noir books share a recognizable set of features, though no single book has all of them:

  • An urban setting, often a city where corruption runs deep
  • Moral ambiguity, where the line between right and wrong blurs
  • Fatalism, with characters who seem doomed or trapped
  • Terse, often first-person narration
  • A flawed or doomed lead
  • A femme fatale, which is common but not required

Crime writer Sara Gran, in her advice on writing noir, argues that the genre is concerned with emotional, psychological and moral life as much as with crime. That helps explain why a noir book can work even when its plot is simple.

Noir vs hardboiled vs mystery

The three terms overlap, but they are usually distinguished like this:

Type Typical lead How it usually ends
Mystery (whodunit) A detective who solves a puzzle The killer is found and order is restored
Hardboiled A tough investigator with a personal code Often partial justice in a corrupt world
Noir A criminal, victim or ordinary person caught in a trap Ruin, with no clean way out

A common shorthand is that a hardboiled hero is a detective with a code, while a noir lead is often a criminal, a victim or an ordinary person heading for ruin. Genre boundaries are fuzzy, and critics disagree about exactly what counts as noir.

Noir beyond the 1940s and the US

Noir did not stay in the 1940s or in America.

  • Neo-noir revisits the style with modern settings and sensibilities. James Ellroy’s L.A. Confidential (1990) and Dennis Lehane’s novels are often cited.
  • Nordic noir brought the style to Scandinavian crime fiction, including Henning Mankell’s novels and Stieg Larsson’s The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (2005).

Noir in comics

Comics have a strong noir tradition. Sin City, Criminal, Blacksad and 100 Bullets all use the tone and themes described above, and each takes a different visual approach. Crime comics boomed after World War II until the Comics Code Authority made them hard to publish. Our noir comics guide covers the best-known titles in more detail.

Common misconceptions

  • Noir and detective fiction are not the same thing. Many noir novels have no detective.
  • A femme fatale is common but not required.
  • Noir does not have to be set in the 1940s or in the US.
  • “Noir” describes tone and outlook, not black-and-white visuals.

The complete guide to comics history

The Most Influential Comic Books of All Time
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →