There is no official answer. The Killing Joke (1988) is the Batman comic most often named as the most controversial. Readers and critics also point to A Death in the Family, All Star Batman & Robin and Batman: Damned. The right pick depends on what you find objectionable, so the content notes below matter.
The Killing Joke (1988)
The Killing Joke is a 48-page one-shot by Alan Moore and Brian Bolland. The Joker shoots Barbara Gordon, paralyzes her and photographs her undressed, to torment her father, Commissioner Gordon. The comic does not show a sexual assault explicitly, but many critics read one as implied. Feminist critics have argued that the violence against Barbara goes too far. Moore has said he regrets how he handled her story.
Barbara survives, but paralyzed. She later became Oracle in Suicide Squad #23 (1989), and she walked again in the New 52 (2011). The story’s ending, including whether Batman kills the Joker, is ambiguous.
A Death in the Family and the 1-900 vote
In Batman #426–429 (1988–89), the Joker beats Jason Todd, the second Robin, and leaves him to die in an explosion. Readers chose his fate through a 1-900 phone vote: 5,343 to kill him and 5,271 to spare him. Reports say the vote drew 10,614 votes over about 36 hours, and that hundreds of those votes came from a single number. The close result is part of why the story is still debated.
All Star Batman & Robin (2005–08)
Frank Miller and Jim Lee’s series depicts a harsh Batman who abuses Dick Grayson, the young Robin, in ways many readers found out of character. The series ran for 10 issues and was left unfinished. It is a common example of a Batman story that divided fans, and it includes content some readers find disturbing.
Batman: Damned (2018)
Brian Azzarello and Lee Bermejo’s Batman: Damned is a DC Black Label series that follows Batman and John Constantine as they investigate the Joker’s murder. The first issue includes a nude panel of Bruce Wayne. Reports say the digital edition censored it, but many print copies sold, and fans split over whether the nudity was necessary or a brave way to show Bruce’s vulnerability.
Other picks and why they divide readers
- Batman: Venom shows Batman becoming addicted to an experimental drug. Some readers found the portrayal of his desperation powerful; others did not like seeing him that way.
- Batman #673, “Joe Chill in Hell,” is an issue of Grant Morrison’s run in which Batman psychologically torments the man who killed his parents. Most fans consider it out of character.
- JLA: Tower of Babel (2000), by Mark Waid, has Batman’s contingency plans for containing his teammates stolen. Readers split over whether Batman’s paranoia is a flaw or a deliberate choice.
- Night Cries deals with a serial killer whose victims are linked to child sexual abuse. It is a grim read, and the topic is severe.
How to judge “controversial”
“Controversial” here means that fans or critics widely objected, that a story sparked real debate, or that it changed a character in a way many readers rejected. A story can be widely admired and still be called controversial. If you are picking up a title for the first time, read the content notes first. The Killing Joke and Night Cries both deal with sexual violence.
For a beginner’s path through Batman’s core stories, see our Batman reading order, which notes The Killing Joke as optional.
Common misconceptions
- Barbara Gordon was not killed in The Killing Joke. She survived, paralyzed.
- The ending of The Killing Joke is ambiguous, not confirmed.
- The Jason Todd vote was close, not a landslide.
- Holy Terror is not a Batman comic. Frank Miller pitched it as Batman against al-Qaeda, but it was published by Legendary Comics in 2011 with a new hero, the Fixer.
For the story of Jason’s return, see Batman: Under the Red Hood.