DC Comics

Batman: Under the Red Hood Comic Review

A review of Batman: Under the Red Hood, Judd Winick's 2005–06 story where Jason Todd returns, with plot, art, the 2010 film and where it fits.

On this page
  1. Story basics
  2. The plot
  3. Jason Todd’s death and return
  4. The debate at the center
  5. Art and the Annual
  6. The 2010 animated film
  7. Who should read it, and where it fits
  8. Common misconceptions

Batman: Under the Red Hood is a 2005–06 storyline by writer Judd Winick. It is a common recommendation for readers who want a Batman story about his methods, rather than a straight fight with a villain. This review reveals the Red Hood’s identity.

Story basics

The arc ran as “Under the Hood” in Batman #635–641 and #645–650, plus Batman Annual #25 (2006). Judd Winick wrote it, and Doug Mahnke drew most of it. Paul Lee and Shane Davis drew the Annual. Batman #642–644 interrupt the run with unrelated stories, such as “War Crimes.”

The arc was later collected as a single trade, Batman: Under the Red Hood (2011). It first appeared in two Under the Hood volumes.

The plot

A new Red Hood moves into Gotham’s drug trade, taking territory from Black Mask (Roman Sionis) and killing crime lieutenants. Batman has to deal with a vigilante who uses lethal methods, and the question of who is behind the mask drives the mystery. The answer is Jason Todd, Batman’s former Robin, back from the dead.

Jason Todd’s death and return

The Joker killed Jason in A Death in the Family (Batman #426–429, 1988–89). Readers chose his fate in a 1-900 phone vote, which narrowly favored his death, 5,343 to 5,271. Reports say the poll drew 10,614 votes over about 36 hours, and that hundreds of those votes came from a single number.

Annual #25 explains his return. Superboy-Prime’s reality-altering punch, from Infinite Crisis, revives Jason in his grave, and Talia al Ghul later places him in a Lazarus Pit.

The debate at the center

Batman and Jason disagree about how Batman should handle the Joker. Jason argues that by not killing him, Batman accepts every future victim. Batman refuses to kill, because he believes that once he crosses that line, he can’t trust himself to stop.

The arc does not settle the argument. In the climax, Jason hands Batman a gun and demands that he kill the Joker. Batman refuses. Critics often say the arc questions whether Batman does enough, without portraying Jason as a hero either. That leaves the reader to weigh both sides.

Art and the Annual

Doug Mahnke’s art carries most of the arc. The Annual, drawn by Paul Lee and Shane Davis, supplies the explanation for Jason’s return.

The 2010 animated film

Batman: Under the Red Hood (2010) was written by Judd Winick, and Bruce Greenwood, Jensen Ackles and John DiMaggio voice Batman, Jason and the Joker. The film runs about 75 minutes. It drops Infinite Crisis, Superboy-Prime and most of the comic’s side plots, so it is not a page-for-page adaptation.

Who should read it, and where it fits

Read the arc after you know Jason Todd’s history from A Death in the Family, because the story depends on it. If you are building a beginner path through Batman, the arc works well after the core stories. See our Batman reading order for where it fits.

If you want a Batman story that questions his methods, this is a strong choice. If you prefer continuous stories, be aware of the three-issue break in the middle.

Common misconceptions

  • The arc’s original title was “Under the Hood.” “Red Hood” came with the trade and film branding.
  • The film is not a straight adaptation. It drops Infinite Crisis, Superboy-Prime and most side plots.
  • The Lazarus Pit did not revive Jason alone. The comic credits Superboy-Prime’s punch first.
  • The phone vote was close, not a landslide.

For why many readers rate the arc so highly, see Why is Batman: Under the Red Hood so good?

The complete guide to dc comics

DC Comics Explained: Earth-11, the Quadrant and the Multiverse
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →